Here's me again, forever on the hunt for the best liquid eye liner. So much that it's becoming borderline obsessive. Make Up For Ever have pretty decent ones, Stila are ok, though flaky... Urban Decay I haven't tried yet, but they are here ready and waiting...
Wet N Wild Mega Liner Liquid Eyeliner are the only drugstore brand of liquid eye liner that I've tried, but they're easily better than the high end brands that were mentioned above. Though MUFE and Stila have the shimmer, Wet N Wild has the longevity, which (IMO) is way more important.
Turquoise is one of the most beautiful shades I've ever seen. I actually felt it was more of a Kelly Green... it's very bright and extremely eye opening. I found this shade to work best layered. They dry pretty quickly so I put one coat on... let it dry, and added another. This kept it from looking patchy.
Black is absolutely night dark black. The blackest of the black. Very easy to apply and nice to use. I also had to layer this like I did with Turquoise. Black dried with a matte finish.
I love that these liquid eyeliners are SO affordable and absolutely are able to compete with the high end liquid liners. You know I slept in these and they only faded a bit? When I did that with other liquid liners they were gone in the morning! The WnW Mega Liners do not flake off or run. However, I do recommend doing your eyes up before your face makeup, because these DO apply wet and as you can see from the photos, will get on your lower lashes.
Wet N Wild Mega Liner Liquid Eyeliner retail for $2.99 each and are available in six shades. They can be found at your local drugstore.